After five years of teasers, delayed opening dates, and a LOT of Instagram comments, Pizzeria Cusumano is finally serving pizza in Collingswood, New Jersey. The long-awaited restaurant officially celebrated its grand opening on Saturday, November 14 2026, giving local pizza lovers something they've been waiting years to experience.
Located at 872 Haddon Avenue, just steps from the Collingswood PATCO station, the new pizzeria brings a different style of pizza to one of South Jersey's most popular dining destinations. And judging by the enthusiastic early reactions, the wait may have been worth it.
Five Years of Teasers, Delays, and Pizza Hype
The story of Pizzeria Cusumano began back in 2021, when owner Sal Cusumano first teased plans for a new restaurant in Collingswood.
Sal is a third-generation pizzaiolo from the South Jersey family behind My Angelo's, with locations in West Berlin, Voorhees, and Riverside.
But opening the new restaurant turned into a much longer journey than anyone expected.
After the initial announcement, a spring 2026 opening was anticipated. That date came and went, followed by another expected opening in October.
Meanwhile, the restaurant's social media accounts continued sharing mouthwatering videos of pizzas that nobody could actually order yet.
The comments became part of the story, with people joking about whether the restaurant would ever open. Some Reddit users even started calling the entire situation a "psy-op."
Fortunately, the speculation finally came to an end in November 2026, when Sal announced his official launch date to be the 14th—and so the doors finally opened.
A Different Kind of Pizza for Collingswood
If you're familiar with the family's classic thin New York-style pizza, don't expect Pizzeria Cusumano to be exactly the same.
Sal spent years developing a lighter dough and brought in an imported oven to create a different pizza experience.
Rather than offering individual slices, the restaurant focuses exclusively on whole pies.
The menu includes several creative combinations alongside familiar favorites.
What's on the Pizzeria Cusumano Menu?
Pizza lovers can choose from options including:
- Pepperoni: A familiar favorite for traditional pizza fans.
- Burrata: A pie featuring the popular creamy cheese.
- Funghetto: One of the restaurant's specialty offerings.
- Fig Jam & Bacon: A sweet-and-savory combination.
- Vodka-roni: One of the most talked-about pizzas from the restaurant's social media teasers.
- Tomato Pie: A classic option for tomato lovers.
- Grandma: A familiar pizza style with plenty of South Jersey appeal.
After years of watching these pizzas appear on Instagram, customers can finally order them for themselves.
A New Addition to Collingswood's Restaurant Scene
Collingswood has built a reputation as one of South Jersey's favorite destinations for dining, shopping, and exploring local businesses.
Haddon Avenue is lined with independent restaurants, coffee shops, boutiques, and neighborhood favorites, creating a downtown atmosphere that attracts visitors from throughout the region.
Pizzeria Cusumano's location at 872 Haddon Avenue places it right in the middle of that activity, with the Collingswood PATCO station just a short walk away.
For residents, it's another convenient dining option close to home. For visitors, it's one more reason to spend an afternoon or evening exploring downtown Collingswood.
And after five years of anticipation, the restaurant certainly isn't arriving without an audience.
Why People Love Living in Collingswood, NJ
Part of what makes a new restaurant opening exciting in Collingswood is the community surrounding it.
The borough offers a blend of small-town charm, walkable streets, independent businesses, and convenient access to Philadelphia.
Throughout the year, residents enjoy popular community traditions like the Collingswood Farmers' Market, May Fair, and Porchfest.
Outdoor destinations such as Knight Park and Cooper River Park provide opportunities to relax, exercise, and spend time outside.
Collingswood's neighborhoods also feature a beautiful mix of historic Victorian homes, classic Craftsman architecture, tree-lined streets, and welcoming front porches.
With its own PATCO station connecting residents to Center City Philadelphia, the town offers a lifestyle that combines neighborhood character with regional convenience.
It's the kind of community where a new pizza restaurant can become a major local conversation before it even opens.
Have You Tried Pizzeria Cusumano Yet?
After years of delays, social media teasers, and plenty of jokes in the comments, Pizzeria Cusumano is finally open for business.
Whether you're curious about the Vodka-roni, interested in the Fig Jam & Bacon, or simply want to see what all the excitement has been about, there's finally an opportunity to find out.
Location: Pizzeria Cusumano, 872 Haddon Avenue, Collingswood, NJ.
Have you been yet? Tell us which pie you ordered and whether it lived up to the hype!
Thinking About Making a Move in South Jersey?
Whether you're buying, selling, or just exploring your options, The JFKLiving Team is here to help. Explore our latest listings to see what's available across South Jersey and Philadelphia.
Fill out the form below, and let's talk about your real estate goals.




.jpg)

